Feeling Overwhelmed by Afterpay? How to Consolidate Your Buy Now, Pay Later Payments

Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) services like Afterpay, Zip, and Klarna have become go-to tools for people wanting to spread out their spending without paying interest. But when you’re juggling multiple accounts across different platforms, keeping up with due dates and amounts can quickly get messy. What starts as a convenient way to manage cash flow can spiral into a confusing cycle of small debts that add up faster than you expect.

If you’re starting to feel overwhelmed by the constant notifications, repayments, and late fees, there are practical ways to take back control. This guide explains why BNPL debt can become tricky to manage, how to consolidate multiple payments into one, and what steps you can take to stay on top of your finances for good.

The Problem with Multiple BNPL Accounts

Using one BNPL app for a few purchases might feel harmless, but once you mix several — say, Afterpay for clothes, Zip for electronics, and Klarna for travel or gifts — things can get complicated. Each service has its own repayment schedule, notification system, and spending limit. If you forget a due date or your bank balance dips unexpectedly, a missed payment can trigger fees or even impact your credit file.

According to ASIC’s Buy Now Pay Later: An industry update report (2020), one in five BNPL users had missed at least one repayment, and about 15% of consumers took out additional loans to cover their BNPL debts. The overlap of multiple small obligations can make it harder to see the full picture — you might only realise how much you owe when your next pay hits and disappears almost instantly.

BNPL platforms don’t always appear on traditional credit reports, meaning lenders might not see your full financial commitments. That can lead to over-borrowing or unexpected cash flow gaps, especially around rent, bills, or groceries.

Signs You Might Need to Consolidate

Consolidating BNPL debt doesn’t mean you’ve failed financially — it’s a smart way to simplify your repayment structure and prevent future stress. You might consider debt consolidation if:

• You’re using more than two BNPL platforms at once
• You’ve started missing repayments or paying late fees regularly
• You’re using new BNPL accounts to pay for essentials, not just discretionary items
• Your direct debits are becoming difficult to track
• You’re experiencing anxiety about checking your account balances
  

If any of these sound familiar, now’s the time to pause, list every BNPL account and the remaining amounts, and look for a more manageable approach.

Step 1: Take Stock of What You Owe

Start by pulling together every BNPL account you have. Check your app history and emails for past purchases, then create a list that includes:

Note: The table above is for illustrative purposes only. Figures and repayment details are examples, not actual data from any provider. Always refer to your BNPL account statements or app for accurate balances and due dates.

Step 2: Consider Consolidating into One Payment

If you’re managing several BNPL balances, one option is to roll them into a single debt. Finding one of the best personal loans for bad credit in Australia might allow you to clear all those scattered payments and focus on just one.

A personal loan with a fixed rate and term can simplify your budget, letting you make predictable repayments over time. Instead of juggling four small instalments with different due dates, you make one consistent payment each week or month.

Here’s how consolidation typically works:

1. Apply for a low-rate or bad credit personal loan from a reputable lender.
2. Use the funds to clear all your BNPL balances in full.
3. Close or pause your BNPL accounts to avoid new spending while you repay the loan.
4. Set up automatic repayments on the new loan to maintain consistency.
   

According to the comparison platform Finder, personal loan rates can start as low as 5.95% p.a. (as of September 2025), depending on your credit profile. That can often be cheaper than repeated BNPL late fees or account charges.

Step 3: Use Tools to Track Payments

If consolidation isn’t the right move for you yet, you can still get organised using payment tracking tools. Apps like MoneyBrilliant, Frollo, or WeMoney sync with your bank accounts and automatically highlight upcoming BNPL deductions.

Alternatively, create a colour-coded spreadsheet or calendar reminder system that flags each payment due date. Setting alerts 24 hours before each debit helps you keep enough funds in your account and avoid penalty fees.

Some BNPL platforms, such as Afterpay, now allow users to change payment dates or pause an instalment for 24 hours if needed. Using these features proactively can help you maintain control without defaulting.

Step 4: Rework Your Budget and Spending Habits

Once your BNPL debt is under control, review your budget to prevent a repeat cycle. Australian banks like ANZ recommend a simple budgeting guideline known as the 50/30/20 rule — allocating roughly 50% of your take-home pay to essential costs, 30% to discretionary spending, and 20% to savings or debt repayment.

If BNPL repayments are eating into your essentials, it’s time to rebalance. Consider:

• Switching to debit cards or prepaid accounts for discretionary spending
• Avoiding new BNPL purchases until all current ones are cleared
• Setting up automatic transfers to a “sinking fund” for future big buys instead of relying on instalments
  

Even small changes like delaying online purchases by 48 hours can reduce impulse spending significantly.

Step 5: Know Where to Get Help

If your BNPL debt has grown beyond what you can manage alone, don’t ignore it. Several free and confidential services can help you get back on track:

• National Debt Helpline (1800 007 007) — free financial counselling and debt advice
• MoneySmart’s Financial Counselling Directory — find a local, accredited adviser
• Financial Rights Legal Centre — guidance on consumer credit and financial hardship options
  

Speaking with a financial counsellor doesn’t affect your credit score and can help you negotiate payment plans or pause interest where possible.

Final Thoughts

It’s easy to lose track when multiple BNPL accounts are quietly drawing from your pay each week. Consolidation can simplify things, but the real key is building awareness and structure around your spending.

If you’re feeling the pressure, take small, steady steps — list your debts, track your payments, and, if it makes sense, roll them into a single manageable loan. Simplifying your repayments is not about judgment; it’s about peace of mind. By taking action now, you’ll be in a much stronger position for the months ahead — and you might even start to enjoy payday again.

Write and Win: Participate in Creative writing Contest & International Essay Contest and win fabulous prizes.

About the Author

'Monomousumi'

Administrator

Disclaimer: Monomousumi is not responsible for any wrong facts presented in the articles by the authors. The opinion, facts, grammatical issues or issues related sentence framing etc. are personal to the respective authors. We have not edited the article. All attempts were taken to prohibit copyright infringement, plagiarism and wrong information. We are strongly against copyright violation. In case of any copyright infringement issues, please write to us.

Visit Website View All Posts