“Build the wall.” “Send them back.” “They drain our taxes.” The language surrounding undocumented immigration is almost always framed as a battle cry, an emergency at the gates. But when you strip away the slogans and study the numbers, a different picture emerges—messier, more contradictory, and deeply financial. Immigration is not just about borders or laws; it is about ledgers of cost and contribution, written in both red and black ink.
Undocumented immigrants, those who reside in a country without legal status, now number in the millions in nations across the globe. The estimate for undocumented person in the U.S. exceeds fourteen million. Their presence undeniably carries weight. The cost of controlling this population through enforcement, removals, detention centers, and border security is billions, every year. Mass deportation has been estimated to cost no less than $315 billion dollars nationally. In 2017, the annual fiscal burden of the undocumented immigration population to U.S. taxpayers was $115.8 billion, related to education, welfare and medical programs without banks. they work, often cash only, which puts government revenues short while legal residents who want work are being left out jobs or training opportunities. For those who see undocumented immigrants as only a taker, the equation is simple: they are a drain, and the country bleeds the taxes for it.
Yet as with any revenue ledger, the other side must be read too. Undocumented immigrants are not idle. They have jobs in agriculture, construction, transportation, and hospitality—the exact sectors of work citizens would like to avoid. Although they do not totally replace native workers, they get the economy running on its flawed mismatched seams ultimately, connecting citizens,, former skilled workers, professionals and especially in the case of healing the youth, to the higher-level managerial and professional occupations. Studies have demonstrated that foreign born workers including undocumented workers constitute about one-fifth of the U.S. labor force. Quieter than many may feel honorable or permissible, these workers allow employers to cut costs, and therefore allow the workforce to serve as a pump. Workers spend what they earn on their consumption which leads to output of jobs. Pay week, no matter how grade the any amount, is returned into the economy by way of groceries, rents, clothing or transportation.
At times the numbers contribution is hidden in plain sight. A recent investigation in Georgia, found over 300 undocumented South Korean citizens working at lee Hyundai’s Battery manufacturing facility. This would not compare to no-skill labor required to get two people moving to Supply Chain. This was proprietary, technical corpses where the site produces items that will perform to the country’s future clean energy economy. They may have been undocumented, restating but were perfectly relevant in an industry that the country’s economic viability relies on to be competitive. Health costs provide additional counterintuitive, outrageous, information for the audience to consider. Undocumented immigrants they are scapegoated for the “clogged” hospitals, used 20% less medical services. They are estimated to account for 3.2% of the population and are billed for only 1.5% of the hospitals bills, regardless of the average citizen, their bills are much lower for healthcare purposes. Schools are not, processes as generating; exterior, undocumented students do not receive fed aid organizational state of colleges, colleges and universities, they pay admitted at out of state tuition rates, creating a more significant revenue opportunity. In sum, the contributions may not be as noticeable as the costs, but they are undeniably present, woven into the nation’s economic fabric.
This dilemma is not just America’s. Spain, the UK, Germany, Hungary—all face the same conundrum. Walls and deportations yield clarity, but not sustainability. Ripping out millions carries immediate fiscal expenses and longer-term inflationary impact—and in the US, removing 7.5 million undocumented workers would project to trigger three years of inflation. The alternative—which increasingly more European countries are choosing—is regularization: treatment for temporary or permanent residency status so that immigrants become less hidden and taxable, legitimate workers. Legalization adds $1.5 trillion to the total US GDP over a decade. The math is clear, yet politics often resists arithmetic.
So where does that leave us? With ambivalence. Undocumented immigrants impose costs, but they also generate growth. They burden, but they also sustain. They exist in the space between fear and necessity. Red ink and black ink bleed together, and thus it is impossible to determine categorically that they are either good or bad for the economy. That’s why debates about immigration sound so false when boiled into slogans: truth is not a chant; it’s an unsolved equation.
The financial story of for undocumented immigrants demands a honesty about both sides of the ledger. Enforcement is costly, public goods are compromised, and some citizens suffer lost opportunities. Nonetheless, crops are harvested, factories are running, classrooms are full with tuition-paying students, and entire industries rely on undocumented hands. To focus solely on one side of the ledger is to misinterpret the ledger. The question is not about whether they are portrayed more positively or negatively, but whether a country could design a system that transform undocumented contributions into recognized, taxable, and sustainable into the economy.
Perhaps the most sobering realization is this: economies are living, not statically permanent, systems. Remove too many people and the system weakens; absorb too many without safeguards and the system buckles. The ledger of undocumented immigration does not become a clear case of gain or loss, but it does force countries to articulate what they value more: punishment or productivity, exclusion or integration, the illusion of purity or the messy arithmetic of growth.
And in the end, the measure of a nation’s wealth may not lie in how high it builds its walls or how fiercely it guards its borders, but in how wisely it counts the people within them—not just the citizens with papers, but the undocumented millions who, silently and relentlessly, already hold up part of its economy.
By: Chimin Joun
Write and Win: Participate in Creative writing Contest & International Essay Contest and win fabulous prizes.
About the Author
